← Resources
SIGNAL · 02

Against the score

Turning your wellbeing into a number feels like progress. Often it is the opposite.

Morrígan2 min read
Morrígan — Signal 02, Against the score

There is a deep assumption in health technology that if you can measure something, you can manage it. Step counts, sleep scores, readiness ratings, mood out of ten. The number promises control. For a great deal of what shapes mental health, the number quietly does harm.

The trouble starts the moment a felt experience becomes a metric. A score invites comparison: to yesterday, to a target, to other people. It converts a bad night or a low mood into a failure with a figure attached. For anxiety in particular, the tracking can become the very thing that feeds it.

What the research suggests

The clinical literature already has a name for part of this. Orthosomnia describes people whose pursuit of perfect sleep data makes their sleep worse. Clinicians increasingly report patients made more anxious, not less, by the devices meant to reassure them. The pattern is not limited to sleep. When a number becomes the goal, the number becomes the source of pressure.

None of this means measurement is useless. It means the object of measurement matters. Counting your steps is fine. Scoring your soul is not. The distinction is whether the metric supports a behavior or sits in judgment of a person.

Counting your steps is fine. Scoring your soul is not.

Observation over scoring

There is a gentler alternative, and it is older than any app. Notice, without grading. Name what you see, without ranking it. 'Your sleep is lifting this week' is an observation you can act on. 'Your sleep score is 62' is a verdict you can only feel measured by.

This is why Morrígan does not give you a number for how you are. It reflects patterns in plain language and leaves the scoring out. A mirror, not a scoreboard. The point is to help you see yourself more clearly, not rate yourself more precisely.

As more people notice how the metrics make them feel, the appetite for one more dashboard is fading. The tools that last will be the ones that help people understand themselves without asking them to keep score.

References

  • Baron KG, et al. (2017). Orthosomnia: the clinical phenomenon of perfectionism driven by sleep-tracking data.
  • Literature on self-monitoring, social comparison, and anxiety in wearable and app use.

More from Signal